Why Choosing the Wrong Agent Could Cost You Thousands

What happens if you choose the wrong real estate agent?
It could cost you tens of thousands of dollars in missed opportunities, poor pricing, ineffective marketing, and long delays on the market. In this blog, we’ll show you exactly why it happens, what to watch out for, and how to avoid choosing the wrong real estate agent, without wasting weeks interviewing agents or relying on guesswork.

What Happens When You Choose the Wrong Real Estate Agent?

When you’re selling your property, the stakes are high. Most sellers are focused on getting the highest possible price, and understandably so, but the agent you choose can make or break that result.

Here are the most common (and costly) outcomes of choosing the wrong real estate agent:

• Overpricing or underpricing the property
• Poor marketing strategy that doesn’t attract buyers
• Lack of local market knowledge
• Slow or no communication during the sale campaign
• Longer days on market, leading to discounted offers
  

These outcomes don’t just impact your finances, they create stress, uncertainty, and can delay your next move. Unfortunately, sellers often don’t realise they’ve made the wrong choice until it’s too late.

How to Choose a Real Estate Agent Who Won’t Cost You Money

Most sellers think how to choose a real estate agent comes down to one thing: commission fees. But that’s only part of the picture. A good agent earns their commission by delivering better results, not just by charging less.

When vetting an agent (or better yet, using an agent comparison tool like Agent Choice), make sure you’re considering:

• Sales experience in your suburb
• Recent results with properties like yours
• A proven marketing strategy
• A realistic pricing approach (not just the highest quote)
• Positive vendor reviews or testimonials
  

If you don’t know what to ask or how to compare those elements, it’s easy to fall into the trap of choosing the wrong real estate agent.

What Makes a Good Real Estate Agent?

There’s no single formula, but great agents tend to have a few key traits:

• Local expertise: They know recent sales, local demand, and buyer behaviours.
• Clear communication: They keep you informed every step of the way.
• Tailored marketing: They invest in the right platforms and presentation.
• Honesty: They give you a realistic price guide — not just one that wins your listing.
• Proven performance: They can show you results from similar properties.
  

On the flip side, red flags to watch for include vague marketing plans, pushy sales tactics, or overpromising on price without justification. These are common signs you’re at risk of choosing the wrong real estate agent and potentially losing out.

Why DIY Agent Selection Is Risky

If you’ve ever tried to find a real estate agent on your own, you’ll know how time-consuming (and confusing) it can be. Many sellers simply pick the agent they’ve heard of, the one their friend used, or whoever quotes the highest price.

The reality?

• Some agents inflate price estimates just to win listings.
• Others underquote to create false urgency and quick sales.
• Marketing inclusions vary wildly, and most vendors don’t know what’s standard.
• Online reviews can be biased, filtered, or even fake.
  

Even asking the right questions to ask a real estate agent isn’t always helpful if you’re not sure what a good answer looks like. That’s why more sellers are turning to agent comparison services and agent matching platforms like Agent Choice to simplify the process.

Why Buyer Psychology Matters (and Why Good Agents Get It)

A key part of a successful property sale is understanding how buyers think, and good agents know how to tap into that. From how a listing is worded, to the timing of the campaign, to how price guides are framed, buyer psychology plays a role in everything.

A poor agent might ignore this entirely. A great one knows how to:

• Create emotional appeal in listings
• Time open homes strategically
• Highlight the right features for your target buyer
  

If you’re interested in how buyer behaviour impacts your final result, this article from ATG offers great insights into buyer psychology and how it shapes property decisions. It’s something good agents master, and bad ones overlook.

How to Choose a Real Estate Agent the Smarter Way

At this point, you might be wondering how you’re supposed to gather all this information, ask all the right questions, and know what a strong proposal looks like, especially if you’ve never sold before.

That’s exactly why Agent Choice exists.

Instead of comparing dozens of agents or relying on guesswork, Agent Choice matches you with a top-performing local agent based on your property type, location, and selling goals. There’s no stress, no pressure, and no hidden fees.

• We analyse recent sales and agent performance data
• We shortlist based on strategy, marketing, and results
• You get one trusted recommendation, tailored to you
  

It’s a smarter, faster, and lower-risk way to avoid choosing the wrong real estate agent.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let the Wrong Agent Cost You

Choosing the wrong real estate agent can lead to overpricing, poor marketing, low offers, and unnecessary stress. But with the right support, it’s avoidable.

You don’t have to become a real estate expert overnight or interview ten agents to make a confident decision. Agent Choice makes it easy to choose the right agent, without the guesswork.

👉 Use Agent Choice now to get matched with a top-performing agent in your area and sell smarter from day one.